Consumer product regulation – costly problems across the board

4 minute read

These days (with just a bit of exaggeration) there’s nearly as many regulations as there are products on the consumer market. It’s truly a mess. Businesses that sell consumer goods face a great many challenges to keep up and comply with different regulators and regulations.

Australian businesses must comply with regulations set by more than a dozen federal agencies, and often those set by individual states.

The consumer product sector already has to contend with cost of living impacts and competition from overseas online retail platforms (on which compliance is often low priority). With very little government co-ordination and harmonisation, the array of disparate rules has become overwhelming and unsustainable. Substantial change is needed to streamline the system and stop the negative impacts on businesses, the economy and national productivity.

Multifaceted problems

I have now published a white paper which I co-authored with colleague Barbara Kerlen: Addressing an ever-growing problem.  Regulation of consumer products in Australia: The unreasonable, cumulative burden on business and productivity.

It’s a very long title, but it conveys the message. The paper highlights the array of problems besetting Australian product regulation.

Some may assume that the amount of regulation is the main problem. Of course, regulations do tend to accumulate – few politicians are prepared to cull redundant ones. But the sheer number is less of an issue than the way regulatory policy is often written and administered.

Our white paper describes how regulations are often

  • written without due consultation with regulated entities
  • imposed by different jurisdictions with unharmonised and conflicting requirements
  • not fully evidence-based
  • written with errors (that are not corrected once flagged by businesses)
  • published without necessary accompanying compliance guidelines
  • increasingly written within government portfolios unfamiliar with product businesses and supply chains, eg. knife sales rules written by police departments, toilet paper rules written by the forestry department
  • administered with no flexibility, despite known compliance difficulties

… among other issues.

Ways to improve

In our white paper, we are seeking a range of measures to address the current mess, including:

A more effective framework

  • Effective application and oversight of the Regulatory Policy, Practice and Performance Framework (RPPPF) for product regulation
  • A framework to manage genuine national alignment and harmonisation, rather than parallel state‑based regimes operating under nominally national laws
  • An avenue to report concerns with, and review, regulatory decision-making

Better regulatory policy

  • Clear jurisdictional and agency boundaries, to prevent regulatory overreach and duplication
  • Stronger international alignment with trusted overseas regulatory regimes, recognising Australia’s position as a relatively small market in global supply chains
  • Meaningful consultation (preferably collaboration) with regulated industries, to ensure regulations are practical, intelligible and capable of real‑world compliance, including co-design with industry where practical
  • Regulation commencement dates that accommodate commercial practicalities (eg. avoid 1 January)
  • Ability to make timely corrections to declared regulations where necessary

A single reference point

  • A single, authoritative platform (eg. business.gov) for regulatory information, including consultation alerts, so businesses can engage, understand and meet their obligations with confidence. This would aggregate various agencies’ listings and provide links to each agency’s website for full information
  • A regulatory grid for co-ordination and planning

Sound, practical, implementation and compliance

  • Effective and practical guidelines published at time of declaration, with ability to progressively adjust as needed
  • Education for regulated businesses, using TGA Learn as a model
  • Power to make interpretations for the ACCC, and others
  • Risk‑based, proportionate enforcement, focused on actual consumer harm rather than technical non‑compliance

We also put forward other reform measures, including the notion of a central ministry for regulation as exists in New Zealand, where the Ministry of Regulation has a role to oversee regulatory capability, policy and implementation.

Some of these ideas were in my earlier white paper Paradigm shift needed for product safety in Australia. Sadly little has changed since then. In fact it’s much worse.

White paper

The white paper Addressing an ever-growing problem.  Regulation of consumer products in Australia: The unreasonable, cumulative burden on business and productivity includes attachments containing:

A table showing the various product categories, regulatory entities and harmonisation levels

An overview of compliance costs in consumer product safety

A slide deck video with examples of recent regulatory missteps

Click on image to download the white paper:

The paper has been sent to senior government ministers and officials, as well as business associations. Barbara and I are hopeful that systematic changes will be made, as the current situation is not sustainable.